Post

Avatar
where is this western comics vs manga discourse. Are you trying to trick me?? I don’t see it. Anyway, comics are good for you.
Avatar
Twitter post. I forgot which one, but it was big on Twitter before portfolio day drowned it out.
Avatar
Oh is that the post I saw complaining about how JP conventions are full of manga while US ones are full of merch/charms? (I saw a thread about that that also remembered to bring up "JP conventions are also WAY cheaper to table at")
Avatar
Yes, that’s the one I think!
Avatar
I think that the table cost differential/state of the comics industry in North America are pretty key differences that said. I suspect it's FAR easier to break into manga and get an indie following over there than over here, given how much bigger relatively speaking the industry is.
Avatar
It's difficult to say. Manga has much more established pathways, but also MUCH greater competition for those available pathways. The pool of professional-level artists is considerably larger in Japan.
Avatar
True, though one could say that about the pool of artists who draw cool stuff but direct those talents at prints and merch, if the competitiveness of getting into artist alleys these days is any indication. There's SO MUCH talent out there, just not aimed at comics.
Avatar
Prints and merch are entirely different skills than sequentially storytelling. That is a key difference. In Japan, they hone their storytelling skills first, art second.
Avatar
Very fair! I'm a little curious if the pipeline for those who hone story is moreso to animation storyboarding instead of to comics, with that in mind.
Avatar
Definitely comics. When I taught high school in Japan there were always manga clubs practicing storytelling and producing full comics.
Avatar
Oh in Japan absolutely. I meant as in in the West. There's so many talented artists online who seem to be storyboard artists by trade.