Post

Avatar
As well-meaning publishers try to navigate the coming storm of state laws against diversity, I hope they'll consider Timothy Snyder's Rule #1 (from his slim book ON TYRANNY).
Avatar
This is why fascism becomes popular in uncertain times? Ppl do this for stability?
Avatar
Yep. The trajectory is most often: - progressive social change - cishet conservative anxiety over privilege loss - rising authoritarians promise return to golden age, - simplify complex social issues into us/them scapegoating, - insist on suspension of democratic norms to eliminate threat
Avatar
I'm going to need some proof for this one. Hitler's rise was not predicated by progressive social change. Quite the opposite, it happened in the wake of Germany's impoverishment by the debts imposed in the treaty of Versailles.
Avatar
a lot of resentments built up over the "cosmopolitanism" of Weimar urban cultural revival of the mid-late 1920s not 100% castigating intellectuals, gay and jewish people, for one
Avatar
You've internalized right-wing propaganda about why people supported the Nazis. It was mostly the national humiliation in WWI.
Avatar
sorry, it's right-wing propaganda to... acknowledge the well documented right-wing reactionary position at the time that the democratic republic's culture was "degenerate"? It was not an actually popular/mainstream opinion much less a legitimate one but that Was what the Nazis believed
Avatar
Okay, so it's not so much that there was social progress in Germany as that the Nazis pushed back against social progress by casting Jewish and homosexual people as "degenerates corrupting pure Germanic culture and blood"? Jewish people were accepted in and integrated into German society before WWI
Avatar
which is how many of them had become German bankers and artists and all the other roles in German society Jewish people had before the Nazis started scapegoating Jewish people and discriminating against Jewish people and taking those jobs away from Jewish people.
Avatar
This article says Jewish people were integrating into German society for a solid hundred years before the Nazi party ever existed, and considering that they had no problem doing so I'd say there wasn't nearly as much antisemitic sentiment then. www.britannica.com/place/German...
Avatar
Life expectancy during that period in Germany was only 40 years, so that's definitely multiple generations where Jewish people were able to immigrate into Germany without any major problems (that didn't also apply to everyone else). www.statista.com/statistics/1...