I respect Levy too, but then lots of folks that I respect are more willing than I am to treat the right side of the legal academy as people worth talking to..
I think it's noteworthy that the decision is getting criticism from people who generally love the Roberts Court even if the precise nature of the criticism makes me roll my eyes and make a jerk off motion.
And while I think the logic and implications of the decision are much more significant, it is also true that Sotomayor completely demolishes the majority on originalist grounds.
