If I were in charge of anime awards, these would be some of my categories:
Best “This Dial Goes to 11” attitude: Gurren Lagann
Best “oh they’re ACTUALLY a badass” arc: Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End
Best Beefy Lady Representation: Dorohedoro
Best Commitment to the (admittedly baffling) Bit: JJBA
Hit The Hardest When It Had No Goddamn Right: Madoka Magika
Made Me Google Japan’s Drug Laws: Dorohedoro (again)
Only Weebs Really Get It: Pop Team Epic
Still Not Sure How This Got Made (complimentary): Cromartie High School
Most Entertaining Bastardization of the Western Canon: Hellsing
Bleakest Invocation of Norman Rockwell Paintings: Texhnolyze
Series Most Likely to End Up in a College Media Studies Curriculum: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Once You’ve Seen It, You See It Fucking Everywhere: Akira
Best Use of Artistic Restraint for Comedy Purposes: Nichijou
That Fucking Dance: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
Highest Concentration of Early Apple Product Homages: Serial Experiments Lain
Best Show To Practice Your Japanese: Polar Bear Cafe
“We’re Really Doing This, Huh”: Kill La Kill
Madoka is a master class in misleading packaging. When you’re three episodes in and she’s still not a magical girl, and you’re starting to wonder what kind of nonsense slow burn they’re on, and then they hit you with THAT?! Goddamn
I want to make my housemate watch it but I think I’m going to have us watch the Sailor Moon reboot first and maybe a couple of other magical girl shows so the WHAT THE FUCK hits harder.
I'm just going to add one more, just because more people need to see it.
Best Western book adaptation (TV): Gankutsuou: The Count Of Monte Cristo
Best western book adaptation (Movie): Howl's Moving Castle
yeah no quibbles there, i think you nailed it (modulo Frieren, which I haven't seen, but from what I hear, I don't doubt your analysis).
I wish I could watch Gurren Lagann again but my ability to look past HI BOOBS and Leeron has waned substantially.
Id also like to nominate Gurren Lagann for the "I wasn't prepared to feel these feels" award after Big Bro.... Well, you know... 😭
Dorohedoro doesn't get enough love! That show is a sleeper hit and yeah, giant woman supremacy!!