Post

Avatar
Burning an american flag is just a way to signal edginess and unseriousness at building any kind of movement
Avatar
What if the very thing you are fighting against is the nationalistic fervor that has led to so much suffering in the world?
Avatar
Sometimes a statement whose only purpose is to shock and offend is the right move.
Avatar
Who is being persuaded by that act?
Avatar
Actions like this oppose the normalization of uncritical support of the government. Burning a flag gives permission to others to raise their voices in whatever ways they choose. And: people who get offended at symbolic actions will never be reliable allies in any case.
Avatar
i do not think it normalizes anything, if the act had persuasive power in the us i wouldn’t be against it but theres a reason that hostile media runs with these images and effective at using them to turn away from support
Avatar
I'd argue that those folks who are turned away, likely never would have supported us. The burning flag is another excuse in their list.
Avatar
It's also a good rallying point for socialists, anarchists, really anyone anti-nationalist to find each other and maybe not be all catty to each other.
Avatar
I do not disagree that its a good rallying point for those people, the issue is how few people meet that description within the us
Avatar
And also that growing the number of socialists to millions will make that rallying point less a thing
Avatar
Avatar
I get the point, and I do think there's room for appealing to people who are put off by radicalism, while also energizing the people who inherently reject the status quo because they can see how rotten it is. Both groups exist, and you can gently nudge the former while firing up the latter.
Avatar
Right the trick is finding the balance between those two without becoming too insular, which i think anyone whos involved in leftist groups can attest have a habit of becoming overly insular
Avatar
Just remember that one it's a proper movement with a real party formation, the two of you aren't allowed to end public conversations on common ground like this.