Post

Avatar
This is brilliant and I think explains 100% of why "the border crisis" has risen to the top of voter concerns: heaps of rightwing misinformation combining with faulty reasoning induced by the regular media not telling people what our immigration policy actually is
The media's intense preference for novelty means that even policy-focused coverage often omits information about current policy. For example, I coded 400 news articles about Medicare and immigration policy. 41% contained zero pieces of information about existing policies in those areas.
Avatar
I think that's true, but I was also speaking to a relative over the holidays who's in his 70s and definitely Dem-aligned who had shockingly rightwing takes on immigration. It's not just lack of information, people also just have very bad instincts in this area.
Avatar
Well that's exactly the point, people's default reasoning is "they should come here legally" or other nonsense because they don't get news about how fucking impossible that is
Avatar
"they should stand in line like my ancestors did," Bill, your ancestors arrived in 1867, the only "line" was to get off the ship.
Avatar
Exactly, “legal immigration” when Ellis Island was open and “legal immigration” now are light years apart from each other. Maybe not enough people have seen “The Godfather, Part II”?
Avatar
your big risk was just how badly they were gonna mangle your name
Avatar
The legend of the Jewish man with almost no English who was named Sean Ferguson by the Ellis Island man comes to me in these moments
Avatar
They shortened by Lithuanian great-grandfather’s name from “Kulikauskas” to “Kulis”.
Avatar
Agreed, but I am sadly unconvinced that would be enough to move the needle.
Avatar
Well I guess let's buy Emily's book and find out
Avatar
It has me thinking that the byzantine policy that almost no one understands and is not part of common public knowledge either intentionally or unintentionally creates a smokescreen for bad actors to manipulate public sentiment.
Avatar
This makes the enormous assumption that US reporters actually know what US immigration policy is.
Avatar
I wonder how much misinfo is reporting laziness, too. As in, it's easier to write a story just quoting someone with influence than it is to actually fact check. And if people complain, well "I was reporting on the person's comments, not on the topic itself"
Avatar
Tbf, heaps of right wing misinformation combining with faulty reasoning induced by the regular media not telling people what our policy is can explain most issues in this country.
Avatar
Yeah that's why I think this book is probably really good