Post

Avatar
Avatar
It's getting so Republican Justices will be afraid to be honest with anyone coming up to talk to them and will treat even their most ardent supporters with deep suspicion.
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
He seemed to think it was.
Avatar
Avatar
So this professor doesn't seem to be MAGA-curious or even traditionally conservative, so I'm going to have to assume that he's coming at this from the position of "don't bother Justices because they're too busy doing important law stuff and don't want to be famous" institutionalism.
Avatar
Which I agree with in theory but definitely disagree violently with in practice because it requires you to accept the fiction that all the Justices are just out there doing important law stuff and not actively pursuing ideological agendas. Which I cannot accept at this time.
Avatar
I got the distinct sense he was on the left, but very afraid that fighting back might jeopardize... something. To a point I'd agree: I don't want to get in the mud, or break laws to fight back (he was very worried about wiretap liability for the recording), but the concerns seemed overwrought here.
Avatar
Even just the wiretap concern seemed misplaced. It was not a private environment! But he seems to think the reporter somehow defrauded Alito into his candor...