Post

Avatar
As an #UncoolTwo50 comparison point, here are the 50 top eligible songs from Acclaimed Music - interesting to see what was left out of our seeding!
Avatar
The equivalent chart for LetsDoIt had much less I would be tempted by - there’s 8 or 9 here I might vote for
Avatar
(But at the same time this shows the huge historical sexism Acclaimed has always reflected!)
Avatar
Thanks for this! I will never understand how 'Bitter Sweet Symphony' has retained that kind of reputation for a quarter of a century. Also thanks for the prompt: Sunday Bloody Sunday should not be eligible because it wasn't released as a single in Ireland. I have added that to the rules doc.
Avatar
On the unseeded songs: Creep, One and Stayin' Alive were definitely in the 500. 'One' doesn't miss the 250 seeds by much. Prince is still a very sore point for me: he only had three songs in the entire 500 and e.g. 'Purple Rain' wasn't picked once! (I really don't think U50 is much of a guide😃)
Avatar
Ah in that case the #50 on this document is Sign O The Times (which is seeded of course)
Avatar
I just said ‘no’ 50 times!
Avatar
I'm surprised you'd heard most of them...
Avatar
Oh, I know them all! Not enough hairspray
Avatar
clearly something must be wrong with their metrics — where in god's name is the hotstepper???
Avatar
lol you know that really is a hell of a list
Avatar
Avatar
#21 is compliant due to Slash. Technically #42 is too. Clemons is on the record but has a small role on this song with only percussion duties. I count E street as compliant when he is showcased like on Born To Run
Avatar
It's credited to 'Bruce Springsteen' - credits determine compliance, as stated in the rules. (the only leeway is on house/dance records with uncredited but obviously female or non-white vocalists)
Avatar
Right. Yes, I always get mixed up on what was credited to both. But that one is just Springsteen. So I stand corrected. It’s best to be precise here.
Avatar
In all honesty, I tend to think that awareness almost guarantees compliance, and erred on the side of generosity when checking before (e.g. Queen are compliant due to Freddie's ancestry). A < 1% failure rate in #Let5D0It suggests people only blow it through ignorance.