Post

Avatar
I see some good ideas being suggested, but here's my entry: he can now *commercially* pirate music, since to really be criminal rather than civil, needs to be commercial. So he could set up the White House's official pirate streaming service. And no one could do anything.
Okay, folks, who is putting together the list of the funniest crimes that Biden should be committing between now and election day to highlight the absurdity of today's immunity ruling? Not the stuff like assassinations. Just stuff to make a point.
Avatar
Runs up against 5th amendment takings clause, no?
Avatar
Does it matter? President is immune.
He’s only immune for official acts. This isn’t one of those.
Avatar
Sure it is. It's for the cultural benefit of Americans.
That doesn’t fit into the guidance outlined in the scotus ruling. The prosecution would easily clear the bar that “cultural benefit” isn’t a core constitutional function of the office.
Though less amusing, I think the answer to the exercise has to be something along the lines of: joining a criminal conspiracy and taking an affirmative step to advance the conspiracy by, e.g., declassifying some relevant information.
Or obstructing justice by threatening to fire DOJ officials, but that's straight out of the ruling so it's cheating.
Avatar
Maybe he could direct some high-ranking military to sleep outside?
Avatar
Lmao I would love to see him order the brass in the nice houses facing the parade ground at Fort McNair to bivouac on the parade ground
Avatar
What's the penalty for declaring non-official acts official again? Oh. Oh no...
The president doesn’t get to unilaterally declare which acts are official.
Avatar
Who's talking about the President? There's nothing stopping the judiciary from determining any act is official. Congress so far has only bothered saying some acts aren't.
Avatar
that was then, this is now
It’s still now. The ruling explicitly directs the district court to make this determination for the conduct charged in the Smith indictment.
Avatar
ok. let me know how that goes
We should get a read on it in a matter of months. Either from the district judge or from Smith adjusting the indictment. We’ll have a good idea how the lower courts will apply this ruling going forward after that.