IMO: There are a lot of problems on 8th Ave through Midtown, but widening the overcrowded sidewalks so people stopped falling onto the streets is not one of them — nyc.streetsblog.org/2024/07/05/m...
When walking that stretch of 8th (often), I love the new NYC pedestrian lane. The meanderthal tourists use the sidewalk, we use the new lane, and you can get to the theater or whatever so much faster.
When driving there (rarely), I hate it.
I work in that neighborhood and having a “pedestrian highway” that tourists don’t really use is a godsend. If they want to do something, have Police crack down on blocking the box.
The theater owners are the ones telling the mayor that they want more traffic lanes, and they are also the ones telling the Governor that congestion pricing is bad (she mentioned theaters in her "explanation" of the pause). Nobody should listen to them.