Once upon a time, me to my cat, to the tune of TMBG's "I Don't Understand You":
I already fed you (I already fed you)
I have already fed you (I already fed you)
I, too, say things to my cats that they couldn't possibly understand. "What? There's four different kinds of food out for you guys. Pick one. You can't always have the treats." (Cat just stares at me, expecting treats. )
my cat has a gravity feeder, his bowl is always full.. every morning we have an arguement about whether or not there's food in his bowl. Its because he's orange.
"But are you certain you really fed me? Could you perhaps have merely pictured yourself feeding me in your mind's eye and created a false memory of feeding me?"
"Even if you did feed me, you must ask yourself, 'Did I feed them well?'?
You're obviously mistaken. That was an entirely different cat who just so happens to look exactly like them, who snuck in and tricked you into feeding them by mistake.
Best to just forget the whole sordid affair and feed your poor starving cat before they die from malnutrition.
#AllCatsAreInnocent
As primary food ape who shares the house with another human, "She's LYING" is something I definitely say to the other human more than once a week. But if I were sole human, I would definitely be addressing Her Highness as "Liar!"