Post

Avatar
setting everything else aside, the idea that no one is willing to sacrifice and die for [western liberalism] is, uh, unsupported in the history
"Democracy Dies In Darkness. And it Deserved To Die." Huh. Why could papers be dying? The world wonders...
Avatar
i have read that hamid post *several* times and genuinely have no idea what the fuck he is talking about
Avatar
its from Suicide of the West: An Essay on the Meaning and Destiny of Liberalism by James Burnham its old anti-liberal tripe imo
Avatar
yeah, i went and found the thread and someone to what end he’s quoting it, and he was like “why does there need to be an end?”. trolly juvenile horseshit.
Avatar
for additional context, Burnham believed that the phantom of liberals and liberalism could not contain the ruthless behavior and truly clever machinations of the "managerial/professional elite" he believed that businessmen would rule and run the world in its entirety, always outwitting any others
Avatar
Well, not saying he was 100% right, but...
Avatar
Orwell had a similar feeling about him. Saw that Burnham had *something* right with how power was being consolidated, but the underlying analysis was bonkers ridiculous. Burnham saw, but did not understand
Avatar
Orwell's biggest criticism of Burnham was that he worshipped power - always welcoming Our New Overlords. Burnham went through a lot of ideological changes to try to be on the winning side.
Avatar
A lot of the conservative thinking can be explained by "which side their bread was buttered on", like Milton Friedman's views on the deregulation of derivatives trading.
Avatar
Yeah. It's easy to criticise capitalist liberal democracies, but proposing sensible improvements is much harder
Avatar
Hamid is simply against secular liberalism because he's a Muslim Brotherhood supporter. Apparently it doesn't matter what kind of authoritarian someone is - Hamid will support them to destroy liberalism. Also like a lot of tankies.
Avatar
Hamid worked for Brookings - which takes so much Qatari money they have a Doha campus. So much respectable discourse about the ME is just plain paid for, but in this case the money amplifies a weirdo ideologue.
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
For a good critique of liberalism, go to Bowles and Gintis
Avatar
or just go interact with random people lol