Post

Avatar
Everyone knows what to do about it. Describe the situation to a 5yo and they'll tell you what to do about it. Hell, ask a LLM what to do about it and it'll tell you "stop using the power-hungry AI." Just because corporations don't like the obvious solution to a problem doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
Power-hungry AI is driving a surge in tech giant carbon emissions. Nobody knows what to do about ittheconversation.com Google, Microsoft and Meta have all reported significant emissions increases due to AI.
Avatar
Framing a problem as deeply complex or insurmountable when the problem is "tech companies are spending billions on fancy autocomplete that is really bad for the environment and will likely never become profitable for them" is a bad journalistic choice.
Avatar
Journalists need to get comfortable calling things stupid when they are clearly stupid. GenAI is stupid. It's bad for everyone except scammers and chip makers. It's not editorializing to point out that GenAI is a mostly useless product and its few uses are minor compared to its profound drawbacks.
Avatar
Ok, so tech companies are clearly not going to do the right thing on GenAI, because they're evil. It falls to government. What if governments create a 5¢ "stupid use of energy" tax for every GenAI query, paid for by tech companies? Make it more expensive for these folks to knowingly burn the planet.
Avatar
If GenAI is as groundbreaking and crucial for the future of humanity as the tech companies all say it is, a 5¢ tax is a small price to pay for its use. But if it's useless, like everyone who isn't a shill for big tech says, everyone will cut way back because taxes make the cost of something real.
Avatar
This is how they frame all of these "dilemmas" caused by unchecked capitalism and greed. "How do we solve homelessness?" "How to we handle climate change?" "How do we protect privacy in a digital age?" We know how, but we're unwilling to tell money No.
Avatar
"Have you tried powering the LLM off and then not powering it on again?"
Avatar
'Nobody knows what to do about it' If it was a device that cured sickness, or fed the hungry, it'd have been switched off 'until the unsustainable power consumption problem was resolved' (never).
Avatar
Also, they have known this for five years. There is no surprise.
Avatar
They just confessed to Goldman Sachs that there's no profit nor route to profit in it. The novelty has already worn off. It's seen as brand poison to use it. WTF are they even doing?
Avatar
It's fascinating, just like RTO where everybody but the execs utterly despise it, but economic and political power is now so wildly unbalanced that it's treated as inevitable instead of ludicrous
Avatar
Now, when I ask Google if a plant is native in my state, it needs to think a minute. Then the answer is always weird.
Avatar
The answer is actually pretty clear and straightforward… Stop that fucking shit!
Avatar
Avatar
Hamster wheels for all those useless people!