A remake doesn't HAVE to be bad. There was a Japanese remake of UNFORGIVEN set in the northern islands during the Meiji era and starring Ken Watanabe in the Clint Eastwood role and it was really fhtagn good.
www.imdb.com/title/tt2347...
Oh, I know, a great many remakes are my favorite movies. Sorcerer, The Thing, even (as the article points out) A Fistful of Dollars. But it's 2024 and I don't personally need an Eastwood western with greenscreens and computer guns
I can't wait for the reductive, anti-intellectual hot takes about westerns, as if it never changed from Stagecoach, and doesn't have a ton of cultural context THAT ISN'T NECESSARILY FROM AMERICA!
Aaugh! (Also it's going to suck)
A shame Westerns have never been self-reflective in any way throughout their entire history (quietly pushes UNFORGIVEN behind the waste bin with one foot)
Even John Ford in his later movies was trying to grapple with the racist tropes he helped popularize. Like, it's a complicated genre as it's so reflective of its time.