So this is just a mock up (so don't judge the Papyrus font lol) but I ws thinking something like this.
I put a dark blue shadow under the main text, then also kept a more subtle version of the lighter glow on top of that as well.
I'm going to give everyone here a big pro tip for the next time you want to trade in or sell a game console
If it looks like either of these, just throw it away and don't bother the people at the store
Update: Suspect has been apprehended.
Neighbor helped me get him into a cat carrier now he's taking him to a friend of his who has rabbits!
Also, rabbits will kick the SHIT outta you!
