Post

Avatar
in what universe is “worst tory defeat in history” not a landslide, man, what is “sort-of” about that, and what are the conditions which would upgrade from “sort-of” to “landslide”? this kind of deliberate obfuscation isn’t exactly the same thing as lying, but it’s closer to lying than anything else
setting aside *whatever* political bent these are coming from, in what fucking world does “sort-of landslide” explain what is happening for the reader? if you are not writing to be clearly understood, then what in the fuck are you doing?
Avatar
I would guess it's related to the vote share being under 40% vs the seat share. I think that's still the wrong way to frame it but I'd wager that's the explanation
Avatar
The issue is that unless the whole piece is about that issue then it's disingenuous. This is how first past the post elections in parliamentary systems always work
Avatar
i agree with that being the likeliest explanation, but, like, that’s moving the goalposts across the state
Avatar
Oh absolutely, hence my second statement
Avatar
Yeah, they're probably seizing on the fact that Labour won a huge majority mainly because the non-Labour vote was so fractured. And perhaps on the fact that voters turnout was the second-lowest in UK history.
Avatar
Good things happening is bad for clicks, subs, and our terminally online publisher
Avatar
The Tories got whooped so bad all the math around how they pick and change their leaders is broken, because it doesn’t scale down to numbers that low We need a word a whole lot more forceful than “landslide” for shit like that
Avatar
Tectonic shift. Just choosing a new leader requires 100 nominations per candidate, & they've only got 121 members now.
Avatar
Avatar
Obviously anyone left of the Tories winning is a tragedy and must be explained away.
Avatar
And immediately undercut. No mandates will be had popular or otherwise, bind versus protect and all.
Avatar
Avatar
Because it wasn't a great result for Labour in anything other than number of seats won. It was a "throw the bums out" vote more than a "gee, we love Labour" vote. They definitely fell down on explaining that, though.
Avatar
you must view this purported labour victory in the context of vibes
Avatar
It's a landslide caused by the right fracturing, meaning in a hypothetical different system it wouldn't be a landslide, only in the actual existing system of the UK is it a landslide. 😅
Avatar
The last time the Tories got this few votes was in 1923. I wonder what the writer thinks a landslide would look like