Post

Avatar
Every so often Reddit surfaces simply the most pure and beautiful human moments
Avatar
Angry sand full of broken shells and hurts my feet, here: rocks and no sand!
Avatar
Ok but actually though that’s great! Why does sand have different textures in different areas? I assume it had to do with the elemental composition of the dirt, and geological shifts like some deserts being dry seabeds, but I don’t know the answers to a lot of these!
Avatar
At its core, it's because we call a lot of different things "sand".
Avatar
Is this a fish and tree things, where sand isn't real?
Avatar
I thought it was birds that aren't real.
Avatar
No, that's a funny conspiracy theory. There really is no scientific definition of fish or tree. It's basically just calling something a square. Except "equilateral rectangle" is more of a definition than fish gets.
Avatar
Avatar
More one where sand is just hard things finely ground up, and you get different behaviors if the hard thing is obsidian, quartz or sea shells.
Avatar
Obsidian sounds bad to walk on
Avatar
Avatar
In a lot of places, it depends on two things especially: transport history and wave energy. Sand grains get tumbled together during transport by rivers or waves, which breaks them into smaller pieces and smooths off the edges. So sand that's been carried a long distance, or which has been washing
Avatar
around for a while, will be finer and smoother. On beaches, the stronger the waves are the coarser material they can carry. So a beach that's exposed to the open ocean might be mostly gravel and cobbles, since all the finer-grained stuff gets washed away by the crashing surf.
Avatar
A beach that's protected by a reef or sandbar or barrier island, which breaks up waves as they pass over and dissipates some of that energy, will be sandier, since the weaker waves can't carry it all off. And a lagoon behind the beach might even have very fine-grained mud!
Avatar
Desert sand is a different animal. It's carried by wind rather than water, so it's all pretty fine-grained; even a howling gale can't carry gravel! Tumbling during wind transport also gives desert sand a microscopic "frosted glass" texture not seen in beach sand.
Avatar
Fun fact: this texture makes desert sand unsuitable for use in concrete, since the cement doesn't stick to the frosted grains properly. For this reason, Saudi Arabia (a famously sandy country) actually imports a lot of sand
Avatar
it depends on composition, size, and the shape of the grains
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Those are all great questions and your nearest geologist or earth scientist would be delighted to talk about them, this should be encouraged.
Avatar
I too would like to dig down as far as possible at the beach for science
Avatar
A few years back the Army didn't get the funding needed to dump fresh sand on our beach so it all got washed away. There were rocks under the sand.
Avatar
Sand is a fractal we’ll never understand!
Avatar
This is great. Instead of ridiculing the question it would be better to start explaining all the facets of sand and how it came to be in the Sahara and other deserts. And why there is (often) sand on the beach in the first place.
Avatar
In absolutely no way am I ridiculing the question?? I love this.
Avatar
Sorry for my misunderstanding.
Avatar
How *did* and come to be in the desert? I had literally never thought of that before. Is it because they used to be underwater? But is it really sand at, say, a creek? What differentiates sand from dirt? I have never thought about this, I'm not a geologist.
Avatar
Short version,, all sand is erosion. Sometimes water,sometimes wind. Some beaches are mostly eroded lava. Some are mostly eroded coral. Some are mostly eroded stone. In deserts it's eroded stone as the topsoil has blown away so no longer retains moisture. The Sahara is only about 20% sand.
Avatar
Plus: There were large lakes and rivers in and around today's Sahara desert. Sahara area was not always a desert. Fun fact: In the movie / book The English Patient a cave in the Sahara plays an important role with ancient cave paintings showing swimmers.
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Oh, I don't think anyone's ridiculing this - the question's rather beautiful. Feels like there's a young mind there, full of curiosity. 😊
Avatar
You're aggressively agreeing, for no apparent reason. Easy error but, can you not?
Avatar
Avatar
This is just so sweet. Sand IS confusing!
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
As someone who used to drive a tractor to clean the beach please do not dig huge holes in the sand you absolutely can sink a tractor
Avatar
Oh man where was this information when I was a 9y old? I could have been building tractor traps??!
Avatar
Yep, and if you hung around until like 2AM you could watch me get stuck in it for several hours until a bigger tractor showed up to pull me out
Avatar
i think this is a question a lot of adults would make fun of but don't actually know the answer.
Avatar
These are perfectly cromulent questions.
Avatar