Post

Avatar
The Beach Boys were better than The Beatles. Don’t believe the propaganda and revisionist history.
Avatar
God Only Knows is better than any Beatles song and it's not even close.
Avatar
Avatar
And Brian Wilson is 10x more likable than any Beatle
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Any? No. Most? Absolutely.
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
and you're right to say it. most beatles songs are very overrated and the rest everyone knows sucks
Avatar
I enjoyed the movie Yesterday, but the idea that Beatles songs could have been introduced to people today and they'd be bangers is so weird. Without any cultural inertia, some of them might land as quirky novelty songs, but mostly not the big hits.
Avatar
I feel like “X walked so Y could fly” is really true in any art. The Beatles feel trite now, but at the time they were trailblazers. It’s like going back to play the first Final Fantasy and realizing it kinda sucks.
Avatar
I haven't seen it, but the premise had me wondering if they intended to explore the influence of the Beatles in kind of a It's A Wonderful Life way, or just have a modern musician introduce the world to "I Want To Hold Your Hand." I'd be into the first one.
Avatar
What’s kind of amazing though is that I didn’t listen to a lot of The Beatles until I was an adult - and I’m still not a huge fan - but I could hear SO MANY other bands in their music. Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, The Doors, *The Pixies*, to name just a few. They were immensely influential.
Avatar
Opinions differ but I am in no way mad
Avatar
I love the Bowie cover of it
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
True, and also not a dig at the Beatles.
Avatar
Avatar
ADay In the Life is better than God Only Knows, and that isn't even the Beatles' best song.
Avatar
A God Only Knows/All My Life mashup would sound dope though
Avatar
Ehhhhh.... Hey Jude is definitely close.
Avatar
That's their best song by a long way though imo
Avatar
The Beach Boys had much more of an influence on the Manson Family than the Beatles did but look who got all the credit
Avatar
Avatar
Dennis Wilson should have made more of an effort to find chicks who put out. Letting Charlie do all the work ended poorly
Avatar
Brits colonize and steal everything
Avatar
Avatar
Fuck Mike Love though
Avatar
Avatar
yo i have actually been saying this for years and everyone just laughs it off like “of course you think that, you’re seventeen california stereotypes piloting a skin suit.”
Avatar
Avatar
Random thought, how do they compare to Don Henley / The Eagles?
Avatar
listen, i am guilty of unironically loving the eagles, and also of occasionally subjecting people to eagles karaoke and that’s one of my toxic traits, and i do have to live with that but the eagles don’t rate, sorry
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
The Beach Boys had more range sonically and Pet Sounds is better than anything The Beatles put out.
Avatar
I am not actually saying I agree or disagree but According to online sources the Beatles considered Pet Sounds the goal they had to surpass so that’s a huge beach boys mark
Avatar
Didn't Brian obsess about making something to match sgt peppers though, which he listened to continuously
Avatar
It was actually a back and forth for a bit but it did start with The Beatles feeling like they had to match Pet Sounds (From what I’ve read)
Avatar
You're right and the bar is actually pretty low, tbh Beatles can't even compete
Avatar
I mean… “Brian Wilson & The Wrecking Crew were better than The Beatles” is a different claim than “The Beach Boys were better than The Beatles”.
Avatar
Avatar
The Beach Boys were a great vocal group but Brian was the only great songwriter. The Beatles had three great songwriters.