Post

Avatar
I think there is basically consensus now among elected Dems that court reform is necessary, if there wasn't before.
Avatar
a moderately sized win in this election will likely be sufficient to do it.
Avatar
Dems taking the trifecta seems like enough. Plus one timely passing among Thomas, Alito, or roberts.
Avatar
if Dems take the trifecta I think that's enough now, full stop
Avatar
do you know if any insider-ish type has put out something about what the likely reform would be? The options, from packing to jurisdiction stripping etc. have a pretty wide range of impact and norm breaking
Avatar
Adding a justice for each circuit+adding a circuit or two is something that I think dems could pitch as serving a functional purpose as well as shifting the balance of the court
Avatar
I’ve long thought this was the sensible approach. Rs and NYT will howl, but it won’t feel like overreach to the vast majority of D voters. Especially now.
Avatar
no and I doubt we'll get that level of detail ahead of an opportunity to do it
Avatar
I don’t know that we *should* really. They should run on countering the corrupt court and then hash out what’s the maximum they can get out of the legislature once they’re there.
Avatar
one of the things it seems like democrats could learn from trump is running on "we're going to do the most beautiful court reform you've ever seen" might work better than "we are going to add x circuits with y judges." *i* want details obvs but that's my job
Avatar
Avatar
I worry about specific promises and then "Biden didn't add five Justices! He lied! No I can't count to fifty and it's very problematic of you to ask!"
Avatar
Durbin’s ethics code will be part of it, but likely not the end of it.
Avatar
If one of them dies, the Court may reform itself; if two of them do, it definitely will. But frankly the system is out of whack and you should pursue it anyway.
Avatar
Phew. I was worried it was going to be a big lift.
Avatar
Avatar
Though I think my point is that there’s a plausible path to doing so (Ie don’t give up hope)