Post

Avatar
I mean, she did beat Trump in the popular vote by about 2 points. On this day in 2020, Biden was up by about 10 in the RCP average and won by about 5. In 2012, Obama was up by 3 and won by 4. In 2008, Obama was up by 6 and won by 7. Doesn't seem like an obvious record of presidential failure to me.
On this day in 2016, 538 had Hillary up by 7 points on Trump. Over the last eight years we've seen polls repeatedly fail, and yet I've never seen an election in which smart people have obsessed about polls, especially strange ones like this.
Avatar
It may well happen, but Biden winning the popular vote in November would break a now five election streak of the national polls being "right" about the winner at this stage of the campaign by RCP average.
Avatar
Lots of flux in 2004, though. Bush happened to be up by 2.5 today and won by 2.4.
Avatar
I really hate the poll unskewing stuff coming from Biden supporters, but I do buy that the RCP average, specifically, has been tainted by trash polls...idk
Avatar
The one weird thing this year is RFK Jr. Some polls have him at 12% and some have him at 3%. He does seem to take evenly from Biden and Trump, and I think he’ll end up not being much of a factor.
Avatar
Yeah, that's a wild card element.
Avatar
Polls help campaigns identify where they can build winning coalitions, so the demographic data in polling is very valuable. (The public election modeling also bakes in higher uncertainty levels in the summer, reducing over time into the fall.)
Avatar
Eight point and five point swings seem like failure to me. Also, I specified the last eight years.
Avatar
Importantly, to the extent they've been off in the last couple of elections, they've been off in underestimating support for Trump.
Avatar
Yes, for those two presidential cycles. No for midterms. My larger point is that public polls this far out are not helpful.
Avatar
The forlorn hope is that they were off bc people were virtue signaling that they didn’t support Trump He has been around so long now that people feel no stigma in being like “I am a Trump guy” so we won’t see a swing towards him *reaching*
Avatar
100%. It's also worth mentioning that these were 4.5 months before the election and that they were still very close to the MOE or beat it. Polls haven't failed.
Avatar
Eight points is nowhere near the MOE.
Avatar
Wait, which was 8 points? I see 5, 5, 1, and 1.
Avatar
Avatar
That's exactly my point. Polls this far out are not particularly useful.
Avatar
If that was your point, I wasn't able to find it here "Over the last eight years we've seen polls repeatedly fail, and yet I've never seen an election in which smart people have obsessed about polls, especially strange ones like this."